Judge Parke: letter to Lord Melbourne attaching Court Report

(c) Sarah Thornton 2025

The Judge sent an umprompted letter to Lord Melbourne apparently to ensure Melbourne did not give in to the immense community pressure to reduce Tom’s death sentence to life in the colonies.

Judge Parke was here! The Coventry Court House is now a cocktail bar, but with the judge’s dais and canopy preserved. In Unwoven, I depicted him seated here under the canopy.

Below is the actual letter to Melbourne, followed by a transcript.

The focus is on the unaccounted for 10 minutes or so when Thomas could have done all the damage (according to Parke and the Prosecutor).
“I am quite satisfied with the Verdict, which could not have been lessened upon the evidence“.
I don’t hold this view. The evidence raised considerable doubt.

Contrast Justice Parke’s letter with that from trade unionist, Percy Fitzpatrick, to MP Edward Ellice (transcriptions following).

Transcript – Justice Parke

Justice Parke didn’t see human beings wracked with poverty. He saw damage to possessions and insisted on the death penalty.

Transcript – Trade Unionist, Percy Fizpatrick

Fitzpatrick saw desperate workers defending their livelihoods from being swallowed by machines. He saw people…humans…and called for mercy.

Court record – attached to Justice Parke’s letter

Above: First page of the official court report
Above: Last page of the court report. Seeing this map for the first time was spine-tingling. I could imagine the court clerk following the proceedings and carefully drawing the map. It brought the whole trial alive.

Ps. The map is actually incorrect. The road labelled ‘Cross Cheaping’ is actually ‘New Buildings’. Refer to the Board of Health Map.

The full transcript of the trial is provided below. It does not record the judge’s comments. I have taken these directly (almost word for word) from the Coventry Herald & Observer report shown on the main Bonus Material page (under “Historic Documents”).

Viewed from a modern lens, some of Parke’s comments are highly prejudicial.